
Arranging a Picture
Thirds and the Golden Ratio
Placement rules, such as the rule of thirds and the golden ratio, claim that some spots in a frame are stronger than others; the evidence for them is thin.
Look at
- Unequal lines divide the frame, and the tree trunk stands on one of them, left of center.
- The horizon runs along another line, a little above the middle.
Georges Seurat
Circus Sideshow (Parade de cirque), 1887–88
Rows of stiff horizontals and verticals invite golden-ratio overlays, yet Roger Fischler's study of Seurat's notes, sketches and paintings, summarized in 1981, found no sign he used the ratio.
A 2014 study of 727 paintings found the rule of thirds plays at most a minor role, and art historian Martin Kemp has found no Renaissance drawing built on a hidden golden ratio.
Image: Project Gutenberg · Public domain